Shop Podiatrist-Loved Comfortable Fall Shoes

It’s time to swap out your summer sandals for fall footwear, and we’ve got you covered with podiatrist-approved options. We asked experts from Northern Illinois Foot & Ankle Specialists to share their favorite comfortable fall shoes, and their picks include Chelsea boots, loafers, sneakers, and more. Browse podiatrist-loved shoes below from brands like Dr. Scholl’s, Naturalizer, and Vionic.

Podiatrist-Loved Fall Shoes

Toms Bailey Ankle Boots

“This cute wedge bootie gives even support and stability to the foot compared to a heeled boot,” Dr. Ashley Lee, DPM, says. “It has a moderate arch support but also can accommodate an additional insert or orthotic if needed. The toe box is decently wide enough compared to other booties to give the toes more room and to accommodate toe deformities, such as hammertoes.” 

Dansko Lexie Slip-On Mules

“These Dansko mules have a built-in arch support and cushion for the heel,” Dr. Natasha Bhagat Long, DPM, explains. “These work well for people who have plantar fasciitis but still want to look nice for the fall season. [They’re great] for casual office wear and even [for pairing] with jeans.”

Sam Edelman Laguna Chelsea Boot

“These [Chelsea boots] are stylish and sturdy,” Michael Fishkin, Certified Pedorthist, says. “They have a lugged outsole for increased traction and structure.” Plan to style them with jeans and a cozy sweater throughout fall and winter, too.

Clarks Westlynn Bella Loafer

“These loafers are a great casual work shoe,” Dr. Lee says. “They have a small heel and a nicely cushioned footbed with arch support, which makes them comfortable enough for all-day wear. The toe box is also roomy.”

Ariat Wexford Chelsea Boot

Not only does Fishkin appreciate that these boots are waterproof, but he also says they have a durable outsole for traction, making them safe for walking in slippery conditions, like in the rain. He adds, “They have a specially designed shank through the midsole for ergonomic support.” 

Vivaia Margot Mary Jane

This season, you can’t go wrong with Mary Janes, and this pair is podiatrist-approved. Dr. Lee shares, “These washable and stylish flats have decent arch support for being so lightweight. [They’re made of] flexible material with a square toe box to accommodate bunions and hammertoes.”

Vionic Uptown Loafer

Dr. Bhagat Long says that these loafers are “sturdy with good support inside.” They feature a removable EVA insole that provides cushioning and a durable rubber sole for traction. And for shoppers with wide feet, the leather loafers are also available in wide sizes, meaning you don’t have to squeeze into ill-fitting shoes. 

Naturalizer Everly Pump

“This closed-toed classic pump is perfect for fall,” Dr. Lee says. “The heel is less than 3 inches, so you get the look of a heel without pressure on the balls of your feet that other higher heeled shoes can cause. Naturalizers are also very comfortable compared to other pumps due to their added cushion, arch support, and roomier toe box.”

Vionic Winny Sneaker

Dr. Lee says, “This classic white sneaker is great year-round. It has built-in arch support and cushioning that is made for all-day wear for running errands and standing for longer periods of time. It also has the APMA (American Podiatric Medical Association) seal of approval.”

Dr. Scholl’s Madison Sneaker

Dr. Bhagat Long appreciates that these Dr. Scholl’s sneakers have a wide toe box to prevent your toes from getting squished. She adds, “You can also remove the liner and add your own arch support, like a Powerstep insert, or a custom orthotic for patients needing additional support. They come in a variety of colors.”

Naturalizer Neela Lace-Up Sneaker

Dr. Bhagat Long also recommends these Naturalizer sneakers. Thanks to the memory foam insole and arch support, your feet will stay comfy all day long. The rounded toe box provides enough space for your toes to spread out, too. Plus, they come in a bunch of cute colors, including black, white with a gum sole, and metallic gold.

Cole Haan 2.Zerogrand Stitchlite Oxford Winterized Sneaker

According to Dr. Bhagat Long, “The mesh material [of these sneakers] allows for expansion for people who need [more room] for their bunions or hammer toes, while not compromising on style.” We appreciate that they’re as easy to wear with leggings as they are with your favorite pair of jeans.