For most American families, a first car is a big milestone. It’s a symbol of freedom, independence and parental pride.
That’s exactly what Craig and Hannah Blanchard envisioned when they surprised their 16-year-old daughter in February with a silver 2017 Toyota RAV4. They had paid $17,000 in full, tapping a home equity loan to make the moment possible. Photos and videos from that day show their daughter beaming behind the wheel, ready to take on the road.
But seven months later, their joy turned into a nightmare.
Deputies from the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office arrived at the Blanchards’ Dunedin home with a tow truck in tow. The SUV, they explained, had been reported stolen.
“They rang the doorbell, Craig told News Channel 8 in Tampa [1]. “He says, you know why we’re here? And I said, no, I don’t know. And he goes, that’s all you have over there. And that is, it’s been stolen.”
The family stood helpless as the RAV4 was hooked up and hauled away. Now, instead of celebrating their daughter’s first car, they’re staring at monthly payments on a loan – and even an insurance bill – for a vehicle they can’t even drive.
“It’s a payment on nothing,” Craig said. “Who wants to do that every month, when I could be putting that money toward other things?”
The Blanchards bought the RAV4 from Vasilios ‘Bill’ Ioannidis, a Dunedin man who owns B&B Spyder Customs, an auto shop in town. Public records show Ioannidis had recently obtained the car through a mechanic’s lien, which is a legal process that allows garages to claim ownership when a customer doesn’t pay repair bills.
The Blanchards paid Ioannidis directly with cashier’s checks, but the title was transferred under his business name. At the time, it all appeared legitimate.
Months later, though, state records flagged the title as ‘canceled’ and placed a ‘stop’ on the vehicle with the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles. That’s when deputies seized it as evidence in an ongoing investigation.
The RAV4 is now sitting in a tow yard. Ioannidis told local reporters he hadn’t known of any issue and promised to ‘make it right.’
For now, the Blanchards are stuck. They’ve lost the car but still carry the debt.
Buying a used car from an independent seller or small auto shop often looks like a bargain. Licensed dealers are subject to consumer protection laws, and the FTC has been active in taking action against these businesses. [2]
But unlike licensed dealerships, private sellers aren’t subject to the same laws. That leaves buyers vulnerable to issues like:
-
Outstanding liens: A bank or mechanic may have a legal claim on the car, even if the seller hands over the keys.
-
Invalid or canceled titles: A document can look official but may not hold up in state records.
-
Stolen vehicles: If a car was stolen before it reached the seller, law enforcement can seize it months or even years later.
When police step in, the buyer usually loses the car, as was the case for the Blanchards, and has little chance of recovering the money spent.
Read more: There’s still a 35% chance of a recession hitting the American economy this year — protect your retirement savings with these 10 essential money moves ASAP
If you’re considering a used car purchase outside of a dealership, here are the steps experts recommend:
-
Double-check the title with your DMV. Don’t just accept the paper copy. Call or visit your state’s Department of Motor Vehicles to confirm the VIN, title number, and registered owner [3].
-
Run a vehicle history report. Services like AutoCheck, Bumper and Carfax can reveal liens, theft reports, accidents, or salvage history. At under $40, it’s cheap insurance against a five-figure mistake [4].
-
Match ID to ownership. If buying from someone, ensure their driver’s license matches the name on the title. If buying from a business, confirm it’s a registered dealer [5].
-
Watch for mechanic liens. If a seller recently obtained the car through a lien, ask for official release paperwork before moving forward.
-
Use secure payment methods. Cash and cashier’s checks can leave you without recourse. Escrow services or verified bank transfers provide more protection.
If you already bought a car that turns out to be stolen or improperly titled, your options are limited but not hopeless:
-
Report it immediately to law enforcement to establish your innocence. According to the National Insurance Crime Bureau, 35% of recovered stolen vehicles are found on the same day as they were taken, and 45% are done so within two days. [6]
-
Alert your lender and insurer to explain the situation and prevent further losses.
-
Seek legal advice as consumer protection attorneys can sometimes help recover funds in fraud cases.
-
Look into restitution programs as some states maintain funds for victims of auto fraud. The Department of Justice suggests that in fraud and financial crimes cases, restitution can be part of the sentence, ordering the offender to pay victims back for actual losses. [7]
The Blanchards’ ordeal is a stark reminder that even the most careful buyers can end up blindsided. What was supposed to be a rite of passage for their daughter has turned into months of stress, debt, and uncertainty.
For other families shopping for a first car, the takeaway is clear: do your homework, verify every document, and never assume a clean title on paper means the deal is safe.
Otherwise, you could end up just like the Blanchards, making payments on a car that got taken away by a tow truck.
Join 200,000+ readers and get Moneywise’s best stories and exclusive interviews first — clear insights curated and delivered weekly. Subscribe now.
At Moneywise, we consider it our responsibility to produce accurate and trustworthy content people can rely on to inform their financial decisions. We rely on vetted sources such as government data, financial records and expert interviews and highlight credible third-party reporting when appropriate.
We are committed to transparency and accountability, correcting errors openly and adhering to the best practices of the journalism industry. For more details, see our editorial ethics and guidelines.
[1]. News Channel 8”Dunedin family’s $17,000 car purchase ends in confusion, seizure”
[2]. Federal Trade Commision“FTC Takes Action Against Online Used Car Dealer Vroom for Deceiving Customers, Failing to Deliver on Time and Provide Required Disclosures”
[3]. DMV Central”Understanding title verification: A comprehensive guide”
[4]. Edmunds”AutoCheck vs. Carfax”
[5]. FTC”Consumer advice”
[6]. NICB”How to Report a Stolen Vehicle”
[7]. DOJ”The Restitution Process (Fraud and/or Financial crimes)”
This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.
